Google Rating
Based on 201 reviews

Johnson County Main Mobile Nav Form

What are the advantages of Hardie Siding vs LP Smartside?

Table of Contents

The exterior of a home is often the first impression, with its siding playing a pivotal role. Over the years, various types of sidings have grown in popularity, but not all have stood the test of time. With Kansas City’s extreme seasonal fluctuations, it’s crucial to select a siding that’s both durable and visually appealing.

Why Durability Matters in Kansas City

hardie siding vs lp smartside

Kansas City experiences significant seasonal changes, from soaring temperatures above 100 degrees in summer to chilling lows below 20 in winter.

The durability of siding becomes paramount in such conditions. A product like James Hardie siding not only offers a pleasing aesthetic but also stands up to the severe elements faced in this region, outlasting its competitors.

Transition from Steel and Vinyl to James Hardie Siding

Our journey in the siding industry has seen numerous transitions. Our company has been around for 47 years. In the initial years, when the business was just taking off under my father’s guidance, the primary focus was on steel siding.

Over time, the market evolved, and the preference shifted towards vinyl, eventually leading us to where we stand today: staunch advocates for James Hardie Fiber Cement siding. This is not just a business decision but a choice rooted in the product’s superior quality and resilience.

Disadvantages of LP SmartSide

While LP SmartSide has its admirers, largely because of its wood composition, it doesn’t quite measure up in terms of longevity.

In a place like Kansas City, where many homes are currently clad in wood siding, the common complaints pertain to wood rot and susceptibility to wood-boring insects.

For homeowners looking to make a lasting investment, the objective is clear: choose a siding that requires minimal maintenance and promises longevity. Unfortunately, LP SmartSide doesn’t quite tick these boxes.

Personal Experience with LP SmartSide

To add a personal touch to the narrative, I recall purchasing a home in 2011 adorned with LP SmartSide. While it looked impressive initially, within a decade, I found myself painting the house twice, indicating its high-maintenance nature.

Advantages and Warranty of James Hardie Fiber Cement

Unlike its LP counterpart, James Hardie Fiber Cement offers a low-maintenance solution. Whether you choose the primed and painted version or one that comes pre-colored from the factory, the finish is expected to last between 10 to 15 years.

Such a promise not only speaks volumes about the product’s quality but also offers peace of mind to homeowners.

Customer Satisfaction and Company Support

The durability and aesthetic appeal of James Hardie Fiber Cement are undeniably impressive, but what truly sets it apart is the backing of a solid warranty and robust company support.

While no product is without its flaws, our partnership with James Hardie ensures that any hiccup is promptly addressed.

Clients have consistently expressed satisfaction with the warranty, and in the rare event of a problem, all they need to do is “contact us”. Our strong local representation, combined with James Hardie’s commitment, ensures every issue is resolved to the client’s satisfaction.

In conclusion

hardie siding vs lp smartside

When considering removing old home siding, it’s vital to choose a replacement that offers both durability and aesthetic appeal.

James Hardie Fiber Cement siding stands as a testament to these qualities, making it a preferred choice for many in regions with challenging weather conditions like Kansas City.

Latest Blog Posts



If you know you want to get your home exterior project done, but are feeling stress about paying for it all at once, we can help.

Our financing partner, GreenSky, has sensible payment plans that work for homeowners who prefer to pay in installments. You can also ask your JoCo Siding & Window Co. sales representative about the details!

Save on James Hardie Siding!

Upgrade Your Siding Today!

By clicking SUBMIT, you authorize Johnson County Siding & Window Co., Inc. to reach out to you with questions about your project, via phone, email, or text. Message/data rates apply. Consent is not a condition of purchase. You may unsubscribe at any time.
Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy

Our Customers LOVE The Results

Johnson County Siding & Window Co.
"Working with Johnson County Siding & Windows was a pleasure. They delivered high quality work swiftly for a reasonable price and were respectful of my home. Highly recommend Johnson County Siding & Windows for window replacement!”

- David D.
Johnson County Siding & Window Co.
"Everyone associated with the company was professional and respectful. Our windows look great, communication was very good, and the time line was manageable. Would recommend!”

- Sheri C.
Johnson County Siding & Window Co.
"We are impressed with the quality of the work and we are very pleased with the value after comparing to other options. The crew that did the siding was absolutely awesome. And we are thrilled with the James Hardie Color Plus Siding for the low maintenance from here on out! Thank you to everyone at Johnson County Siding & Window from their sales person to their lead manager and to the crew!”

- Sharon M.

Areas We Serve

Serving the Kansas City Metro Area, Including Olathe, Overland Park, and Leawood See a Full List of the Cities We Serve
Google Rating
Based on 201 reviews

May Promotion


Save $100 per window

when replacing 6 or more windows with new Andersen Residential Windows.

Expires May 31, 2024.