Google Rating
Based on 201 reviews

Johnson County Main Mobile Nav Form

What are the advantages of Hardie Siding vs Vinyl Siding?

Table of Contents

When it comes to deciding on the best siding for your home, the debate between James Hardie Siding and vinyl siding is one to consider seriously. Each offers its advantages, but understanding their differences can guide homeowners in making the best choice.

Durability Comparison: James Hardie vs. Vinyl Siding

hardie siding vs vinyl siding

When evaluating siding options, the durability factor cannot be stressed enough. After all, siding’s primary purpose is to shield your home from the elements. Between the two options, James Hardie Siding stands out with its significant rigidity compared to vinyl siding.

This robust nature of James Hardie fiber cement siding lends it superior durability, which is often the main point of distinction when juxtaposing the two materials.

Aesthetic Comparison: James Hardie vs. Vinyl Siding

Aesthetics play a massive role in homeowners’ decisions when it comes to siding. While many desire the timeless look of wood, the associated maintenance can be off-putting.

This is where James Hardie fiber cement siding takes the spotlight. It offers an aesthetically pleasing, wood-like appearance, often deceiving the common observer into thinking it’s genuine wood.

Contrastingly, vinyl siding, despite its merits, doesn’t quite capture that authentic wood look. One can typically identify a house with vinyl siding from a distance, a feat that James Hardie Siding masterfully evades.

Importance of Installation

Regardless of the siding material, proper installation is paramount. At Johnson County Siding and Window, they emphasize the importance of meticulous installation, whether dealing with vinyl, steel, stucco, stone, or James Hardie fiber cement.

Getting it right at the installation phase ensures the longevity of your project. A detailed approach during installation ensures that even after 5, 10, or 15 years, homeowners can gaze at their exteriors with the same pride and satisfaction as when it was newly done.

Why Painting Vinyl Siding is Not Recommended

Vinyl siding, though versatile in many aspects, has its limitations – especially when it comes to painting. Attempting to paint vinyl siding can lead to undesirable outcomes, such as revealing the original color due to the material’s expansion and contraction through different seasons.

This behavior, especially in areas with pronounced seasonal shifts like Kansas City, means that the aesthetic appeal and functionality of vinyl siding can be compromised if painted. In essence, vinyl siding isn’t designed to hold paint, and painting it can lead to both aesthetic and performance issues.

Our Recommendation

In the realm of siding options, Johnson County Siding and Window proudly endorse James Hardie siding as their premier exterior cladding material. Being an elite preferred Hardie contractor, their trust in the product’s quality, aesthetics, and durability stands testimony to the product’s excellence.


hardie siding vs vinyl siding

When weighing between Hardie Siding and vinyl siding, factors like durability, aesthetics, and adaptability play a pivotal role. For those looking to get the perfect blend of aesthetics and performance, James Hardie Siding emerges as a strong contender.

Should you have any further queries or need guidance on your next home exterior venture, don’t hesitate to contact us. We’re here to help!

Latest Blog Posts



If you know you want to get your home exterior project done, but are feeling stress about paying for it all at once, we can help.

Our financing partner, GreenSky, has sensible payment plans that work for homeowners who prefer to pay in installments. You can also ask your JoCo Siding & Window Co. sales representative about the details!

Save on James Hardie Siding!

Upgrade Your Siding Today!

By clicking SUBMIT, you authorize Johnson County Siding & Window Co., Inc. to reach out to you with questions about your project, via phone, email, or text. Message/data rates apply. Consent is not a condition of purchase. You may unsubscribe at any time.
Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy

Our Customers LOVE The Results

Johnson County Siding & Window Co.
"Working with Johnson County Siding & Windows was a pleasure. They delivered high quality work swiftly for a reasonable price and were respectful of my home. Highly recommend Johnson County Siding & Windows for window replacement!”

- David D.
Johnson County Siding & Window Co.
"Everyone associated with the company was professional and respectful. Our windows look great, communication was very good, and the time line was manageable. Would recommend!”

- Sheri C.
Johnson County Siding & Window Co.
"We are impressed with the quality of the work and we are very pleased with the value after comparing to other options. The crew that did the siding was absolutely awesome. And we are thrilled with the James Hardie Color Plus Siding for the low maintenance from here on out! Thank you to everyone at Johnson County Siding & Window from their sales person to their lead manager and to the crew!”

- Sharon M.

Areas We Serve

Serving the Kansas City Metro Area, Including Olathe, Overland Park, and Leawood See a Full List of the Cities We Serve
Google Rating
Based on 201 reviews

May Promotion


Save $100 per window

when replacing 6 or more windows with new Andersen Residential Windows.

Expires May 31, 2024.